|
In the search for deep penetration for stopping
dangerous game we came across this unique bullet design. We ordered up a few in
order to do some testing in 44 caliber. The plan was to test both in the .44
magnum and in the .444 Marlin. This would give us performance results across a
wide velocity range.
These bullets are machined out of a brass type
material. They are hollow in the rear and filled with lead. Unlike solid brass
bullets, the lead core adds weight and keeps the bullets shorter than a solid
brass bullet would be. However, these are unlike any other jacketed lead core
bullet we've ever seen. Being machined with thick walls and a solid brass tip,
they do not deform. The lead core adds weight but the strength of the bullet is
in the brass jacket.
The quality of the bullets was outstanding. We
measured several of them and found the dimensions consistent. The weight of the
bullets was also very well controlled and variations between bullets were
insignificant.
We loaded these bullets into .44 magnum and .444
Marlin cases and worked up loads until we got to what we considered
reasonable velocity. It is likely that more velocity could be obtained but at
$2.50 per bullet we were only willing to use up a limited number to work up test
loads. In the .44 Magnum we used the 270 grain while for the .444 Marlin we used
the 300 grain offering. Velocities out of a 4-inch .44 magnum barrel were in the
range of 1200 feet per second. Out of a 16-inch rifle barrel, these same loads traveled
in the 1500 feet per second range. The 300 grain bullets from the 161/4-inch
.444
Marlin barrel hit 1900 feet per second. Out of a stock 22-inch barrel, we have no
doubt that another 200 or more feet per second would be gained. The bottom line
is that more velocity is probably not necessary based on the performance of
these bullets shown below. We doubt another 100 feet per second would make any
difference in terminal performance.
The only number that really matters with
this sort of load is penetration. Using our wet paper and hardwood test stand we
went to the range to find out how it performed. As a control we used TrueShot 310 grain
hard cast bullets in the .44 magnum and Beartooth 330 grain hard cast bullets in the 444
Marlin. Velocities of the lead hard cast bullets were in the same ballpark as
the Punch bullets and therefore made for a good comparison. The test stand
consisted of a sandwich of 3/4 inch hardwood, 12 inches of wet news print,
another 3/4 inch hardwood sheet, 12 inches of wet news print, more 3/4 inch
hardwood, 12 inches of wet news print, an additional 3/4 inch hardwood layer, 12
inches of wet news print and finally 3/4 inch of hardwood to end the stack.
Overall the test medium was just over 50 inches long.
The penetration results are as follows shot at 10
feet from the muzzle:
| |
Penetration |
Notes |
| .44 Magnum 270 grain Punch bullet @
1200 fps |
40" |
No deformation |
| .44 Magnum 310 grain WFN hard cast
lead @ 1275 fps |
35" |
No deformation |
| .44 Magnum 270 grain Punch bullet @
1500 fps |
> 50" |
Bullet exited test stand |
| .44 Magnum 300 grain WFN hard cast
lead @ 1550 fps |
31" |
Tip deformed and bullet bent |
| .444 Marlin 300 grain Punch bullet at
1900 fps |
>50" |
Bullet exited test stand |
| .444 Marlin 330 grain WFN hard cast
lead @ 2000 fps |
50" |
Bullet found in final hardwood block. Nose
deformed but otherwise intact. |
These
results show that the hard brass Punch bullets have an advantage across all
velocity levels. While the advantage is small at lower speeds it becomes
significant the faster the bullet is traveling. On a subsequent day we added
another 12 inches to the stack and shot an additional 300 grain .444 Marlin load
into it. This stack was also fully penetrated showing that the penetration of
this load is at least 62 inches.
As far as accuracy is concerned, we could easily keep
2 inches at 100 yards from our .444 Marlin with XO peep sights.
The hard cast lead bullets did a good job in all
cases and would have been very effective on dangerous game. We have used both of
these lead bullets on big game in the past and their performance was excellent.
However, the Punch bullets are in a different league when it comes to raw
penetration. If you are looking for maximum straight through penetration for
hunting very large game or for defense against large bears this bullet is well worth
considering. However, for smaller game the performance of the hard cast lead
bullets is more than enough and the price is considerably less.
|